My reaction to this book was sad because of what happens in the end. I would recommend this book to 4th and 5th graders. It showed how the South and North hated each other at the time.

I found this book to be really boring and it didn’t really engage me into it, I wouldn’t read this book again. I’d say the only interesting part in this book is when Noah loses half of his arm and they are in the hospital and watching all the soldiers limbs be torn off. I wouldn’t recommend this book to anyone because I didn’t find this interesting.

I liked this book very much but the ending was really sad. I love how Catrina is such a strong minded person and does what she wants not what the world wants. I recommend this book to anyone who likes a good drama. Warning- This book contains content that may be unsuitable for anyone younger than seventh grade.

I would recommend this to someone who likes action and a bit of romance almost and adventure. It got really good around page 90 or so. The book ended with a big cliffhanger which didn’t make me super impressed with the ending.